|
|
Maurice Kassimir & Associates, P.C.
We are pleased to announce a new location! |
|
Effective January 1st, 2015 | |
Our new Address will be | |
1375 Broadway, 23rd Fl. New York, NY 10018 |
|
Tel: 212.944.1377 | |
email: lawyers@mkpclaw.com website: www.mkpclaw.com |
|
We Look Forward To Your Visit. |
New York State Estate Tax Changes: How to Potentially Save Millions in New York Estate Taxes |
||||||||||||||
Effective April 1, 2014, New York State substantially changed its rules regarding estate taxes. The biggest changes concern the size of the estate tax exemption and how the estate tax is calculated. For most, New York State estate taxes have been reduced. For some, New York State estates taxes remain very high. The rules are quite complicated. However, with proper planning, significant New York estate taxes can be saved or eliminated for those who would otherwise be subject to estate taxes.
NEW LAW Prior to April 1, 2014, the New York State estate tax exemption was only $1 million. The estate of a New York resident whose New York taxable estate was greater than $1 million had to pay an estate tax to New York on the taxable amount over $1 million. However, as of April 1, 2014, there have been incremental increases in the New York State estate tax exemption which will continue until January 1, 2019, at which point the New York State estate tax exemption will “catch up” to the federal exemption. The federal exemption is $5,430,000 in 2015, and under current law, is indexed for inflation each year. The following chart summarizes the scheduled increases in the New York State estate tax exemption:
The rising New York State estate tax exemption sounds great at first, but along with the increase came a new and bizarre way of calculating the estate’s tax base. If the New York taxable estate is greater than 5% of the exemption amount, the tax is calculated on the entire amount of the taxable estate rather than only the amount over the exemption. This rule is terrible for New York residents whose estates exceed the New York State exemption by more than 5% While we cannot know exactly how indexing will impact the exemption by 2019, we will assume for purposes of this discussion that it will reach $6 million by 2019. Therefore, a New York taxable estate of $6 million would result in no New York or federal estate tax. However, if a New York taxable estate exceeds the exemption by more than 5% of the exemption (or $300,000), a New York estate tax will be payable. As an example, a New York taxable estate of $6.5 million would generate a New York State estate tax of $574,000 (or approximately 8.83%). However, compared to paying no tax on $6 million, the marginal tax rate on the additional $500,000 is a whopping 114.8%! In this example, every dollar over the assumed exemption results in a tax of almost $1.15. PROPER PLANNING IS VITAL FOR MARRIED COUPLES For married couples, it is particularly critical that the New York exemption is not wasted at the death of the first spouse. While federal law allows a transfer of the unused exemption to the surviving spouse under the doctrine of portability, New York law does not have an equivalent statute. Therefore, the first spouse’s New York exemption will be lost if not used at the first death. As a result, if a couple with a $12 million estate leaves everything to the surviving spouse, no federal or New York estate tax would be payable at the first death (due to the unlimited marital deduction), but a New York State estate tax would be payable at the second death of $1,386,800 (on the entire $12 million). With proper planning, this outcome could be avoided. IMPLEMENTATION OF PLAN The first step is to ensure that that each spouse separately owns at least the New York State exemption amount. This may involve separating jointly held assets and/or transferring assets from one spouse to the other. In addition, both spouses must have properly drafted Wills providing for an exemption trust at the first death for the available New York State estate tax exemption. The surviving spouse can retain access to the assets in the exemption trust by being a beneficiary of the trust. This strategy will allow for the maximum amount to be held in the exemption trust at the death of the first spouse regardless of which spouse passes away first. Therefore, if the first spouse to die has a taxable estate of $6 million and the surviving spouse also has a taxable estate of $6 million, all estate tax can be eliminated! This is a much better result than the example above. CONCLUSION It is very important that all available estate planning tools be utilized to maximize tax savings in light of the current law. This advice is particularly important for New York State residents and those nonresidents with significant real property located within New York. Although the new rules in New York can be detrimental to taxpayers, with proper planning they can be used to your advantage. The suggestions made in this article may not be appropriate for you, but other planning strategies may achieve similar results |
To: High Net Worth Clients Date: March 1, 2008
Subject: Estate Planning – Grantor Retained Annuity Trusts (GRATs)
The recent turmoil in the markets is not necessarily all bad news. Certain estate planning vehicles have become particularly attractive in today’s market because they outperform when interest rates are low and allow you to remove undervalued or appreciating assets from your estate. This will occur once the stock market reverses recent trends. One particularly effective vehicle is the Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (“GRAT”). A GRAT is an effective planning strategy for transferring your assets to your children at a substantially discounted gift tax cost. With estate tax rates for New York residents of 55%, the GRAT can be a very important planning tool. A GRAT is an ideal vehicle for transferring equities and other assets out of your estate that currently have appreciation potential in excess of 3.6% per annum. In a GRAT, the grantor (trust creator) contributes assets to the trust and receives a fixed annuity for a specified term of years. The assets remaining in the GRAT at the end of the term will pass estate and gift tax-free to the trust beneficiaries.
Example:
The following chart is an illustration of the benefits of a GRAT with a 5-year term. The calculation assumes 10%, 15% and 20% annual rates of return. The calculation assumes an initial contribution to the GRAT of $1 million in equities or other appreciating assets. Note that other assets such as stock in a closely held business could have excellent results.
Assumed Growth Rate |
Required Annual Annuity Payment Retained by Grantor |
Amount Removed from Estate After 5 Years |
10% |
$222,109 |
$254,515 |
15% |
$222,109 |
$513,817 |
20% |
$222,109 |
$835,477 |
This chart reflects how much property would be removed from your estate on a $1 million transfer after only five years. The amount removed from the estate will continue to grow after the 5-year term as the trust assets continue to appreciate in value. As an example, if $500,000 was removed after five years and it continues to appreciate at 10%, in 30 years the amount removed from the estate will be nearly $9 million (assuming the grantor pays all income taxes). Enhanced planning can result if multiple GRATs are created with different types of assets (for example, a separate GRAT for a long-term cap fund, short term value fund, international fund, hedge fund, etc.). Also, the term of the GRAT can be as low as 2 years.
In addition, because a GRAT is treated as a grantor trust for income tax purposes, the grantor will pay all the tax on the income generated by the trust assets, meaning that the trust principal in the trust will continue to grow outside of the grantor’s estate without any reduction for income tax payments. Over time, this will result in very significant estate tax savings.
Please contact us to discuss whether creating a GRAT is appropriate for you.
Circular 230 Disclosure: Internal Revenue Service regulations provide that, for the purpose of avoiding certain penalties under the Internal Revenue Code, taxpayers may rely only on opinions of counsel that meet specific requirements set forth in the regulations, including a requirement that such opinions contain extensive factual and legal discussion and analysis. Any tax advice that may be contained herein does not constitute an opinion that meets the requirements of the regulations. Any such tax advice therefore cannot be used, and was not intended or written to be used, for the purpose of avoiding federal tax penalties that the Internal Revenue Service may attempt to impose.
Individuals who embark on an estate plan can benefit from establishing trusts. There are many different types of trusts that can be created to accomplish different objectives. Creating a trust can provide advantages during your lifetime and to your heirs after your death. When you set up a trust, you (the grantor) transfer assets to a separate legal entity that holds your assets and disburses them according to your objectives. Because you determine who will serve as trustee, certain trusts let you continue to maintain control over your assets even after you have transferred them to the trust. Which type or types of trusts you decide to implement are dependent on your particular facts.
Trusts can accomplish many important estate-planning goals. They can ensure the sound management of your assets after your death; they can protect your property from creditors; they can minimize or reduce probate; they can guarantee that your estate passes to your heirs exactly as you wish; they can provide funding for multiple generations; they can fulfill your charitable goals and provide income tax benefits, and most importantly, they can reduce estate taxes.
Different types of trusts are designed to accomplish a variety of lifetime and after-death objectives. Some of these include Living Trusts, Charitable Lead or Remainder Trusts, Qualified Terminable Interest Trusts, Credit Shelter Trusts, Qualified Personal Residence Trusts, Marital Deduction Trusts, Generation Skipping Trusts, Grantor Retained Annuity Trusts, Intentionally Defective Grantor Trusts, Dynasty Trusts, Supplemental Needs Trusts, Insurance Trusts , and the list continues.
Depending on your family situation, your wealth, your health, and your age, a plan can be implemented which utilizes a combination of these trusts to best integrate your lifetime and testamentary objectives and minimize estate taxes.
Questions?
If you have any questions regarding this matter or any other estate planning techniques, please contact a Maurice Kassimir & Associates, P.C. Trusts & Estates attorney or e-mail us: mkassimir@mkpclaw.com.
A Living Trust is an alternative to a traditional Will. Both a Will and Living Trust direct how your probate assets[1] will be distributed upon your death. They may be revised at any time prior to your death. The provisions of the Living Trust will also govern your assets during your lifetime. You will be the sole beneficiary of the trust during that time, and the Trustee may be you alone and/or someone else you select. A Living Trust can be revoked.
Since your assets, whether disposed of under a Will or Living Trust, will still be subject to estate taxes, there is no death tax benefit to utilizing one over the other. However, there are significant differences between the two which may make one a preferred alternative.
If you:
1. Want to avoid the costs and delays of probate;
2. Have concerns about a Will contest;
3. Have tangible property or realty in other states;
4. Have privacy concerns; and/or
5. Are concerned about the smooth transition of your estate upon your death and/or incapacity;
then a Living Trust would be the correct choice for you as it will more favorably address these issues.
However, to ensure you reap the complete benefits of this planning, it is important that you transfer all of your probate assets to the trust during your lifetime. This is the most time consuming and costly aspect of Living Trust planning. It is as if you are probating your estate while you are alive. If any of these assets are omitted from the trust, probate will most likely be necessary. Therefore, it is often customary to prepare a simple “pour-over” Will in conjunction with the Living Trust that directs all excluded assets be added to the Living Trust at your death. If the issues delineated above are not of particular concern to you or you are averse to transferring all of your assets to a lifetime trust now (such transfers can be time consuming and costly), an all encompassing Will would be appropriate for you. Typically, we only recommend a Living Trust if the client is concerned about disability within a few years or sooner
Questions?
If you have any questions regarding this matter or any other estate planning techniques, please contact a Maurice Kassimir & Associates, P.C. Trusts & Estates attorney or e-mail us: sklawyers@skpclaw.com.
[1] Probate assets are assets held in your own name. Excluded from the probate estate are joint accounts, retirement accounts with beneficiaries other than the estate, and insurance policies where the estate is not the beneficiary.
Most insureds maintain life insurance policies to replace lost earnings, maintain their family’s standard of living and perhaps provide liquidity for estate taxes in the event of their death. Typically, however, little or no consideration is given to policy ownership and beneficiary designations. If no designation is made at all, the proceeds will be paid to the insured’s estate. If the insured’s Will directs the proceeds to a surviving spouse, estate tax will not be imposed on the proceeds. But if the insured has no Will, or if there is no surviving spouse, there may be an immediate federal estate tax of up to 46% on the value of the proceeds.
Many insureds will have thought to designate their spouse as the primary beneficiary and their children as contingent beneficiaries of their policies. As stated above, proceeds paid to a surviving spouse will not be subject to estate tax. But if the spouse predeceases the insured or they die in a common accident, an unfortunate result occurs. Insurance proceeds which may be urgently needed by the insured’s children (particularly if they are minors) will be fully exposed to federal and state estate tax, meaning that the survivors may receive less than one-half of the proceeds; a disastrous result.
Insureds who are competently advised by their attorneys (or their insurance agents) upon purchasing insurance policies will likely be told to create an irrevocable life insurance trust (an “ILIT”) to serve as the owner and beneficiary of the policy. If the policy is purchased directly by the ILIT, and provided the insured retains no “incidents of ownership” with respect to the policy (which include the right to borrow from the policy or change the beneficiary), the proceeds of the policy will not be included in the insured’s estate for estate tax purposes and will therefore not be subject to estate tax, provided the trust is correctly administered.
The disadvantage of using an ILIT as a policy owner lies simply in the fact that an ILIT, by its terms, must be irrevocable. The insured will not be able to directly access the cash surrender value of the policy. Moreover, the trust terms cannot change even if family circumstances do. However, a considerable amount of flexibility can be built into an ILIT to anticipate changes.
For example, if the insured and his/her spouse later divorce, the insured would probably not want his spouse to be a beneficiary of the ILIT. Therefore, the trust terms may specify that the spouse shall only be a beneficiary after the death of the insured in the event that he or she was “married to and living with the insured as husband and wife at the time of the insured’s death.”
Or should the insured’s child have a disability or exhibit extreme bad judgment and irresponsibility regarding his or her choices in life, the Trustees may be given the power to retain trust income and principal and spend it for the child’s benefit, instead of paying out the principal and income directly to the child upon attaining a certain age.
The ownership status and beneficiary designations for all your life insurance policies (including group policies provided by McKinsey & Company) should be reviewed as soon as possible to ensure that they meet with your family’s needs and are structured in the most tax effective way possible.
Questions?
If you have any questions regarding this matter, insurance planning or any other estate planning techniques, please contact a Maurice Kassimir & Associates, P.C. Trusts & Estates attorney or e-mail us: sklawyers@skpclaw.com.
A disclaimer Will is a useful estate planning tool which provides flexibility while estate tax laws remain in flux. Typically married couples want the surviving spouse to have as much wealth as he or she needs throughout his or her lifetime. Most Wills direct the appointed Executor to administer the terms of the Will, terms which are set in stone. Often the Will instructs the funding of a bypass (or credit shelter trust) before giving the balance to the surviving spouse. The bypass trust is funded with the maximum available estate tax exemption (currently $3.5 million). The terms of the trust are usually for the benefit of the surviving spouse and/or children to be paid ultimately to the children upon the surviving spouse’s death.
A disclaimer Will does not force the creation of a bypass trust. Rather, it leaves the entire estate to the spouse but gives the spouse a disclaimer right allowing the surviving spouse to elect to transfer all or a portion of the available estate tax exemption to fund the bypass trust after the death of the first spouse should it makes sense at that time. Upon the death of the first spouse, the surviving spouse has 9 months to disclaim a portion of the estate.
Rising lifetime exemptions mean that traditional Wills which create mandatory bypass trusts are not necessarily what the testator would have wanted. Currently, the estate tax exemption is $3.5 million dollars (it used to be only $600,000). Suppose a husband dies with an estate worth $2.5 million dollars. Under a traditional Will as described in the first paragraph, the entire estate would be held in trust for his wife during her lifetime and she would receive nothing outright. The husband believed the trust would be funded with $600,000 (the exemption when the Will was drafted), and that his wife would receive $1.9 million. A disclaimer Will allows the surviving spouse to decide how much of the exemption he or she wants to use at the time of the first spouse’s death. This is often more practical than forcing the full exemption. Assuming rising estate tax exemptions, forcing the use of the bypass trust may not be what the decedent would have wanted.
A disclaimer is also a flexible way to maneuver around the state estate tax. Many states have de-coupled from the federal estate tax system, and impose a separate estate tax. For example, New York’s exemption remains at $1,000,000. This means that using the entire federal exemption of $3.5 million will result in a New York estate tax of over $200,000 on the additional $2.5 million of federal exemption. If the spouse decides to use only $1,000,000 of exemption, the state estate tax can be avoided.
Whether a disclaimer Will is right for you depends on your individual facts and circumstances.
Questions?
If you have any questions regarding this matter or any other estate planning techniques, please contact a Maurice Kassimir & Associates, P.C. Trusts & Estates attorney or e-mail us: sklawyers@skpclaw.com.
Generally, if you give someone money or property during your lifetime, you may be subject to federal gift tax. However, most gifts are not subject to the gift tax. For instance, you can give up to the annual exclusion amount ($13,000 in 2006) to as many individuals as you like, every year, without making a taxable gift, and without the recipients owing an income tax on the gifts. And you can make up to $1,000,000 in taxable gifts above the annual exclusion, total, in your lifetime, before you start owing any federal gift tax (state lifetime exemptions may be lower). Implementing a variety of estate planning techniques can leverage the $1,000,000 exemption. Embarking on a regular gift-giving program can be a very effective way to transfer substantial assets out of your estate, free from gift and estate taxes, to your children or other loved ones. This technique of estate tax planning can drastically reduce your taxable estate, thereby reducing your estate tax liability.
Another basic gifting strategy to reduce your estate is through direct payments of tuition or medical expenses. Direct payments of tuition or medical expenses for another person (regardless whether that other person is related to you) is not a gift for gift tax purposes. Each person has an unlimited exclusion for qualified education and medical expenses. In order to qualify for this exclusion, payments must be made to the school or medical provider directly — not to the person that will be receiving the education or medical benefits.
The following example illustrates this point:
Karen wants to help her sister’s daughter attend medical school. Karen sends the school $30,000 for a year’s tuition. She also sends her niece $13,000 to help with books, supplies and rent. Due to the value of Karen’s gift to her niece falling within the annual exclusion, neither payment is reportable for gift tax purposes. If she had sent her sister $43,000 directly and her sister had paid the school, Karen would have made a taxable gift in the amount of $30,000 ($43,000 less annual exclusion of $13,000) which would have reduced her $1,000,000 lifetime exclusion by $30,000.
If your children and/or grandchildren are incurring tuition and medical costs, you can pay these expenses directly without incurring any gift tax obligation. Over time, this can result in a meaningful reduction of your estate, while helping the people you love.
Questions?
If you have any questions regarding this matter or any other estate planning techniques, please contact a Maurice Kassimir & Associates, P.C. Trusts & Estates attorney or e-mail us: sklawyers@skpclaw.com.
Under federal gift tax laws, each individual is currently permitted to gift up to $13,000 in cash or other assets to as many donees as desired each calendar year without any gift tax consequences. In addition, if the individual is married, husband and wife may jointly gift $26,000 to each donee. These gifts are often referred to as “annual exclusion gifts” are in addition to the individual’s $1 million lifetime gift tax exemption. However, unlike the gift tax exemption which may be used at anytime during an individual’s lifetime (or if not used can be utilized via the estate tax exemption at death), annual exclusion gifts can only be used in the applicable calendar year. Thus, if the annual exclusions for a particular year are not used, they will be wasted.
Annual exclusion gifts can be made to donees either outright or in trust. If the gifts are in trust they may be made for the benefit of one or several donees. An annual exclusion trust for one donee is often made under Internal Revenue Code 2503(c), which requires that the donee have a right to terminate the trust assets at age 21. In the alternative, an annual exclusion trust (or “Crummey Trust”) can be established for the benefit of one or several donees without the 2503(c) termination right as long as each donee (for a period of time) has a right of withdrawal over contributions made to the trust. Such withdrawal right is referred to as a “Crummey” power and allows the individual to greatly leverage his (and his spouse’s) annual exclusion gifts by contributing all available annual exclusion gifts to one trust. As an example, if a husband and wife have 4 kids and 8 grandchildren (i.e. 12 donees), they can make tax-free gifts of $312,000 each year to an irrevocable trust with Crummey powers.
As with all lifetime gifts, the main benefit of such planning is the ability to remove the gifted asset from the individual’s estate. At the minimum, this means the value of the asset will not be subject to estate tax at the individual’s death. In addition, since the asset is out of the estate, any appreciation inures to the benefit of the donee free of estate tax. If the same asset had remained in the individual’s estate, it’s current value and future appreciation would be subject to estate tax prior to distribution to the donee. As an example, a father can gift an asset valued at $26,000 to his daughter in 2009 with no tax consequences. Thus, the daughter will receive the full $26,000 value. However, if the father were to instead leave the asset to his daughter under his Will in 2009, the daughter would only receive $13,000, as the asset would be reduced by an approximate 50% estate tax. This result becomes more substantial with an appreciating asset.
Therefore, it is very important that these gifts are appropriately planned for and factored into every estate plan, from the most basic to the most complicated. Overtime, making regular annual exclusion gifts can greatly reduce your taxable estate.
Questions?
If you have any questions regarding this matter or any other estate planning techniques, please contact a Maurice Kassimir & Associates, P.C. Trusts & Estates attorney or e-mail us: mkassimir@mkpclaw.com.
This amount was historically $10,000, but has been indexed for inflation since 1998.
Everyone born into this world dies. It is also quite true that you will take nothing with you. Certainly, you are much beloved by your family and that your eventual passing will cause them great grief. Should you not wish to augment their grief further, and perhaps turn it into feelings of resentment and recrimination, you must execute a Will before your death. If you do not do so, the division of your assets will be determined by the laws of the state in which you reside (which cleverly presume to know your mind).
Let’s use a concrete example. You have not implemented any estate planning during your lifetime. You have no Will and your gross estate is worth $10 million. Your spouse, if you are married, will be entitled to one-half of your estate if you are a resident of New York. Your children will be entitled to the remainder. Your spouse may not appreciate this. Furthermore, if he or she is less grief-stricken than you might wish, your spouse may decide to bestow that $5 million on a new spouse who is considerably less worthy than you might have expected. If your current spouse is the spouse of a second marriage and you have children from a prior marriage, it is likely that your children from the prior marriage will never see a penny of this money. Your children will not appreciate this. There may also be a struggle as to how the respective shares are funded. And as you have left no instructions as to who will manage your estate (an executor would have been appointed in your non-existent Will), it may be years before these important issue are resolved and anyone sees any of your assets.
Additionally, a state and federal marital deduction will be available to protect the value of the property passing to your spouse from estate taxes. But the value of the property passing to your children will not. Your children may be delighted to hear that they will immediately receive one-half of your estate, but they will be less delighted when Uncle Sam and Governor Paterson present them with bills for estate taxes in the amount of $2,500,000, leaving them with a paltry $2,500,000. This is not a tragedy, but you might have done much better for all concerned.
With even minimum estate planning and a Will, here is how these results change: After making annual exclusion gifts to your children during your lifetime ($13,000/yr per child, or $26,000/yr per child if you are married), you might specify in your Will that your children (in trust, if they are minors) will immediately be entitled to property in the amount of the estate tax exemption amount, which is currently $3.5 million, upon which no tax will be imposed. You might make additional gifts of property to your children outside your Will (beyond the $3.5 million exemption amount) through life insurance proceeds from an insurance trust you created during your lifetime. The insurance trust will be structured in such a way as to prevent the imposition of estate tax on the proceeds. In this way, these amounts passing to your children will not be reduced due to the imposition of estate taxes. Your spouse will receive the remainder of your estate in a lifetime trust created under your Will from which he or she will be entitled to all income for life, annually. The trust will ensure that on the death of your spouse, the remaining trust property will be distributed to your children. Guardians will be appointed and trusts can be created in your Will for minor children (those under the age of 18) so that their persons and property are properly cared for until they reach whatever age or ages you determine.
If your spouse does not survive you, failure to appoint Guardians may result in a custody battle between your and your deceased spouse’s families who may both want to raise the children. Property can also continue in trust for the benefit of your children if they later prove to be less responsible than you would like, preserving their assets and providing creditor protection.
If all members of your immediate family die in a common disaster, the “ultimate disposition” clause of your Will may determine how your property is to be distributed (siblings, friends, charities, etc.) rather than leaving the determination to state statute.
Survivorship life insurance may be purchased (in trust) to provide for estate taxes at your spouse’s death, to once again protect the property passing to your children from estate tax. Fiduciaries of your own choosing will be appointed to manage your estate and the property held in trust for your spouse and children. Does this sound any better? It should.
If you are willing to do nothing more than sign a Will and are married at the time of your death, you can at least ensure that there will be no imposition of estate taxes until the death of your spouse.
Unless causing additional grief and strife among your family members is the goal of your estate planning (or lack thereof), please attend to these important matters now so that your family members will appreciate your thoughtfulness and consideration later.
Questions?
If you have any questions regarding this matter or any other estate planning techniques, please contact a Maurice Kassimir & Associates, P.C. Trusts & Estates attorney or e-mail us: sklawyers@skpclaw.com.